Remember when urgency was the whole playbook? End-of-quarter pricing, the expiring discount, the “my CFO can only hold this until Friday” theatrics? I ran all of it, with my full passion behind it.
I was in a discussion over the weekend on why enterprise deals actually die, and I gave an answer I’ve been circling for years now and wanted to articulate it more in detail. Most of the deals you lose will not go to a competitor. They’ll go to no decision. More and more these days when you’re selling an AI tool, the buyer is barraged with options, you’ll see this pattern only increase and the urgency play is the nail in the coffin.
Why? Because the fear in those deals was never FOMO. It’s FOMU. Fear of messing up.
Those two require opposite behavior from you.
If a buyer is afraid of missing out, more urgency helps them move. If a buyer is afraid of getting this wrong, more urgency is just more fear stacked on a person who already doesn’t want to decide. You push, they freeze… and they do the one thing that has never gotten anybody fired. Don’t get me wrong now – urgency isn’t dead. It’s just that applying it to a frightened buyer is like revving the engine at someone who’s afraid to merge. You’re not making them faster. You’re making them certain the highway is dangerous.
The Test
Here’s how I know which fear I’m actually looking at, and it takes ten seconds.
If the critical event can move a couple of weeks, it’s still a critical event. If it can move a month, it’s still a critical event. If it can move quarters, it was never a critical event. There is no consequence of no action. The critical event is everything. And if you can’t find one… good luck closing it.
It would be nice to have a new car. That’s not an event. My lease is up and I’m walking to work on the first now that’s an event. I do enjoy walking more than driving btw… but it doesn’t really fit the analogy, so give me a break!
What to do about it
So before you send another ROI model — and I’ve sent beautiful ones into deals that were already dead — go find out what actually happens to the human being across the table if this slips two quarters. Not the company. The person. Does their project lose funding, does their initiative get handed to someone else, does anything at all change about their Tuesday?
If the answer is nothing, you don’t have a deal yet. You have a conversation.
Run that test on your forecast this week and see how much of it survives.